Nellie Moynahan & Niece Mary Broderick

I was delighted to come across this 1939 news clipping recently from the Windsor Star. 

It made me think about the life of my great-aunt Nellie Moynahan (1865-1940) and her niece Mary whom she raised.

Source: Clipped from The Windsor Star, 11 Apr 1939, Tue, Page 16

On This Day: May 12

Wedding Day May 12, 1903
Patrick Broderick and Clara Moynahan
(Photo from private collection of Bernard Broderick)

On this day in 1903, Patrick Broderick married Clara Moynahan at St Mary's Roman Catholic Church in Maidstone, Ontario.

St. Mary's R.C. Church, Maidstone, Ontario
Image Source: Maidstone Cemetery Records

St Mary's church is located on Lot 293, North Talbot Rd., Highway 3, Maidstone, Ontario.

Many  of  our ancestors are buried in the cemetery there (https://essex.ogs.on.ca/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Maidstone-ST-MARYs-Ess2818-INDEX.pdf)

Source: Online publication - Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2007.Original data - Gabriel Drouin, comp. Drouin Collection. Montreal, Quebec, Canada: Institut Généalogique Drouin.Original data: Gabriel Drouin, comp. Drouin Collection. Montreal, Quebec,

Patrick had his brother Leo W. Broderick (who later became a detective) as his best man, and Clara had her sister Maud Moynahan (who later married Frank Flannery) as her maid of honour.

Photo of Moynahan sisters Maud Agnes and Clara
(Photo from private collection of Frank Lyons)

Unfortunately, Clara (Moynahan) Broderick died in 1919 at the young age of 37 years (after a lingering illness) leaving her husband Patrick with five children aged 18 months to 15 years.

Source: The Border Cities Star - Dec 13, 1919

At 51 years of age, Patrick remarried American-born Mary Josephine Kuehne (1876-1938) on November 28, 1922 in the Roman Catholic church in Amherstburg. Josephine was born in Cleveland, Ohio to Joseph Kuehne (born in Switzerland) and Sarah Darragh (born in Cleveland, Ohio)

Source: Essex Free Press (Essex, ON), December 8, 1922

The Broderick-Moynahan Family Tree

The Broderick-Moynahan Family Tree

I have written previously of Patrick and Clara and some of their children

• 52 Ancestors No. 7: My Oral History Interview with Bernard Broderick  
• 52 Ancestors No. 8: Christian Brother: Bernard Broderick 
• 52 Ancestors No. 34: Brother Berchmans F.S.C. - A "True Son of De La Salle" 
• 52 Ancestors No.41: Nurse Agnes (Broderick) Casey

I have not yet written histories on the Workmans (Indiana) , the Wheelers (California) and the Lyons (Windsor) who have descended from this marriage. My research has benefited greatly from an online ancestry connection to a Lyons distant cousin. I am very grateful for that.

More family facts

• Frank Broderick and Clara Moynahan's children were not only cousins to John Moynahan and Mary Broderick's children (like my grandfather Ernest Moynahan), they were double first cousins: They have both sets of grandparents in common.
• Double Cousins have happened more than once in our family tree
• Matthew Moynahan and Catherine Carr and Timothy Moynahan and Julia Ann Carr
• A new stone was erected for Patrick and Clara Broderick in 1989 (see photo below)

Bernard Broderick (1916-1992) son of Patrick and Clara Broderick
(Picture taken in 1989 at Bernard's parents new stone
at St Mary's Cemetery, Maidstone, Ontario)

52 Ancestors No. 7: My Oral History Interview with Bernard Broderick

Bernard Broderick (1916-1992)
(Picture taken in 1989 at Bernard's parents new stone
at St Mary's Cemetery, Maidstone, Ontario)

This is the seventh of 52 blog posts for the 2015 edition of the 52 Ancestors challenge. I have been blogging my family history for the #52Ancestors challenge since it began in 2014.

#52Ancestors asks bloggers to "have one blog post each week devoted to a specific ancestor. It could be a story, a biography, a photograph, an outline of a research problem — anything that focuses on one ancestor.”

This week's blog post is about my ancestor Bernard Broderick (1916-1992) with whom I had the opportunity to record a family history oral interview in November 1987.

Bernard's Family

The BDM Story

The story that can be gleamed from birth, death, marriage (BDM) and obituary records shows that Bernard's mother Clara (Moynahan) died in 1919 at the young age of 37 years  (after a lingering illness) leaving her husband and five children aged 18 months to 15 years.

Bernard's father Patrick remarried in November 1922 Miss Josephine Kuehne of Amherstburg. Josephine died sixteen years later in 1938.

Patrick died in 1943. He lived for 20 years in the Border Cities at 431 Wellington, Windsor, Ontario after retiring form life as a farmer in Maidstone, Ontario.

All but one of Patrick and Clara's children eventually moved away from Windsor :

• Agnes Broderick (1904-1984) married Michael Casey and moved to Detroit, Michigan.
• Genevieve Broderick (1908-2003) married Chas Wheeler and moved to Chicago, Illinois.
• Lorraine Broderick (1910-1976) married Fred Workman and moved to South Bend,  Indiana.
• Bernard Broderick ( 1916-1992) joined the Christian Brothers at 13 years of age and lived in Africa for twenty years.
• Mary Broderick (1917-?) married Edward Lyons and lived in Roseland, Ontario.

The Oral History Story

In November 1987 I had the privelege of sitting with my father and Bernard Broderick to reminisce about our family history in Windsor, Ontario. Bernard's family is doubly related to mine in that we both descend from the same two Broderick and Moynahan lineages

Bernard Broderick pictured with his mother Clara (Moynahan) Broderick in 1918
Picture taken at John Moynahan's Parent Ave. home when Clara was visiting with her brother.
(Clara died December 1919)

Through our discussions in 1987, many more details emerged about this family that could never be known without the benefit of an oral history interview. Bernard told us:

"I am not that useful because I left Windsor and the family and went out at about thirteen years of age. I went and studied with the Brothers. Since that time I've taught in Quebec and ...Ontario...and they never let me get to Windsor for some reason."

Bernard Broderick at the Seminary

About Bernard's mother Clara (1882-1919):

"although my mother was a Moynahan - I never knew her - she died too young, um, although I do remember incidents that happened......."...."She was - what do you call? - a seamstress making hats and dresses..."

"She (Clara) had eight children, but in those days, there was not the medical facilities they have today. If you had ten children you were lucky if you had five that continued you know. So I think that they had five that lived. A number of them died, and it was an interesting thing - there was the oldest of the Moynahan girls (your grandfather was the second oldest) but the oldest was Nellie, her name was Ellen but they called her Nellie. She was like the godfather...she acted as midwife, and she took over. She was....domineering..""

About Clara's death (when Bernard was three years old):

"...when my mother died my father moved to Windsor And, uh, believe it or not we had money because I do know that he owned a farm - I remember hearing as a small boy that he had paid $7200 for that house - well that was a lot of money in those days. Then he bought another house. But my mother wasn't there and that was bad. We suffered because of that. Oh we suffered terribly. I was sent to a relative at River Canard......." (the Dufours)

About Bernard's father Patrick: When asked "was your father a big man?" "He was about 240 lbs."

About Bernard's siblings:

• Mary: "then my baby sister, she must have been only five, old Aunt Nellie took her in and kept her from the time she was five until she was about twenty...."......" Mary was a clever girl - she had finished high school and she had started nursing and so forth and she just loved this guy and he is a wonderful man." ........"That has been a wonderful marriage"
• Two oldest sisters: "There are my two oldes sisters (pointing at a picture - see below). She's (Genevieve) is still living in California. She's about 80 now..."

Bernards two eldest sisters: Agnes and Genevieve
(circa 1909-1910)

Bernard passed away in 1992 in Toronto. His words recorded from our brief 1987 meeting have proved invaluable to my family history research.

I encourage all family historians to seize the opportunity to sit with a recorder and/or pen and paper and capture the details from the past that exist in the memories of our living family members. Below are some great web links to help.

Oral History Links

• Oral History Question Lists (from Family Tree)
• A Script for Video or Audio Interviews with Family Members (USGenWeb)
• UCLA Family History Sample Outline and Questions
• Family Search: Creating Oral Histories
• The Smithsonian Folklife and Oral History Inverviewing Guide (pdf)
• Oral History Society: Tips for Family Historians
• Guide for Interviewing Family Members (Okeechobee Genealogical Society)
• Family Tree UK - Interview Your Family Sheet 1 (pdf)
• Family Tree UK - Interview Your Family Sheet 2 (pdf)
• Family Tree UK - Interview Your Family Sheet 3 (pdf)
• Family Tree UK - Interview Your Family Sheet 4 (pdf)
• Family Tree UK - Interview Your Family Sheet 5 (pdf)
• Family Tree UK - Interview Your Family Sheet 6 (pdf)